Two Questions to Ask Before You Copy a Competitor's Marketing Move
Watching a competitor do something new and feeling the urge to match it is one of the most natural reactions in business — and one of the easiest ways to waste a quarter chasing a strategy that was never actually working, or was working for reasons that don't apply to you. 💖 A little scepticism before you copy saves a lot of wasted effort after.
What most businesses get wrong
The most common mistake is assuming visibility means success — a competitor running a flashy new campaign or offer might genuinely be doing well, or might be burning cash trying to find out if it works, and from the outside those look identical. The second mistake is copying the tactic without the underlying capability that made it work for them, like a support team big enough to handle the volume it generates.
- "Do we actually know this is working for them?" — Look for real signals (sustained repetition over months, genuine engagement, not just posting once) rather than assuming a single visible move equals success.
- "Would this work for our customers, not just theirs?" — A move built for a younger, price-sensitive audience won't automatically translate to an older, loyalty-driven one, even in the same industry.
If both answers are genuinely yes, adapt the underlying idea to your own voice rather than copying it directly — a lookalike campaign is easy to spot and rarely performs as well as the original.
How to build this into a habit
When you spot a competitor move worth noticing, don't react immediately — note it somewhere and revisit it in a week. Most reactive copying happens in the heat of the moment; a short delay is usually enough to tell the difference between a genuine strategic shift worth studying and a one-off post that caught your eye. If you do decide to respond, respond with your own version of the underlying idea, not a lookalike of their execution.
Mistakes to avoid
- Reacting to a single visible move as if it's proven, sustained success.
- Copying a tactic without the capability (team, budget, systems) that made it work for the original business.
- Losing your own brand voice by mimicking someone else's execution too closely.
- Making a reactive decision in the moment instead of giving it a short, deliberate pause first.
- Assuming what works for a competitor's customers will automatically work for yours.
Frequently asked questions
Isn't it smart to learn from what competitors are doing?
Absolutely — watching the market is genuinely useful. The distinction is between learning from a move (understanding why it might work) and reflexively copying it without that understanding, which is where most wasted effort happens.
What if we're falling behind and need to react fast?
Even under pressure, the two-question filter takes minutes, not weeks — it's not about slowing you down significantly, just avoiding a purely reactive decision made from anxiety rather than judgement.
How do we tell if a competitor's move is actually working?
Look for repetition and consistency over time rather than a single post or launch — genuinely working strategies tend to get repeated and refined, while ones that flop are often quietly dropped after a few weeks.
Is it ever fine to just copy something directly?
Rarely, and even then it's worth adapting the tone and details to your own brand — a direct copy is easy for customers (and the original business) to notice, and it does little to build your own distinct identity in the market.
Keep reading 🤍
I help Gold Coast and Brisbane businesses grow with branding, websites and marketing that actually works.
Work with me ✦