Beyond Google: Should You Bother With Trustpilot, ProductReview or Facebook Reviews?
We get asked this constantly by business owners who've just discovered a review sitting on a platform they didn't even know existed — usually not a glowing one. The instinct is to panic and try to "cover everywhere." That's the wrong instinct. 💖 Managing reputation across five platforms badly is worse than managing two well — an abandoned profile with one unanswered one-star review sitting there for two years looks worse than no profile at all. The real question isn't "should I be on all of them" — it's which one or two actually matter for how your customers decide.
What most businesses get wrong
- Treating all review platforms as equally important, when in reality Google dominates decision-making for anything location-based, and the others matter far less by comparison.
- Claiming a profile on a platform (Trustpilot, ProductReview) purely because a competitor has one, without checking whether their own customers actually use it to research purchases.
- Setting up a secondary profile, getting a burst of early reviews, and then abandoning it — an unmonitored profile with unanswered negative reviews is actively worse than not existing there at all.
- Not realising some platforms (notably Facebook) let reviews be turned off entirely if you genuinely can't commit to managing them, and treating that as a failure rather than a legitimate choice.
The review-platform priority framework
Tier 1 — Always prioritise: Google Business Profile
Shows directly in Maps and search results, influences local rankings, and is where the overwhelming majority of "is this business any good" searches happen. Non-negotiable for any business with a physical location or service area.
Tier 2 — Prioritise if it matches your model:
- Trustpilot: worth claiming and actively managing if you sell online, operate nationally, or compete against businesses that are already there — it's widely trusted for e-commerce and services bought sight-unseen.
- ProductReview.com.au: worth it for Australian consumer-facing brands, especially where price comparison and "has anyone actually used this" research happens before purchase — strong for retail, trades, insurance, telco-adjacent services.
Tier 3 — Only if it's already a live channel:
- Facebook reviews/recommendations: matters mainly if your audience is already active on your Facebook page. If your page is quiet, a handful of reviews there won't move the needle — but you do need to decide deliberately whether to leave reviews enabled or turn them off, rather than leaving it to default and ignoring it.
The decision test: before claiming a new platform, ask "would a customer of mine actually go here to check us out before buying?" If you're not confident the answer is yes, don't commit resources to actively managing it — a dormant profile is a liability, not an asset.
How to actually manage more than one platform without burning out
If a second platform genuinely matters, the mechanics need to stay simple but consistent: a weekly calendar reminder to check every claimed profile, not just Google. Respond to every negative review within 24–48 hours, on every platform, with the same tone and honesty you'd use on Google — an unanswered negative review on a secondary platform damages trust more than the review itself did. And when asking happy customers for a review, name the platform if it genuinely matters ("if you've got 30 seconds, a Trustpilot review helps a lot") rather than assuming they'll find the right one.
Mistakes to avoid
- Don't spread review-request effort evenly across every platform — concentrate asks on Google first, and only branch out once that's solid.
- Don't copy-paste the exact same response to every platform without reading context — it reads as robotic and customers do sometimes compare.
- Don't ignore a platform just because you don't "like" it — if your customers check it, manage it, regardless of personal preference.
- Don't incentivise reviews on any platform with discounts or freebies — most platforms' terms prohibit it, and it can be flagged as fake engagement.
Frequently asked questions
Is it worth paying for a reputation management tool to monitor multiple platforms?
Sometimes — it depends on volume. Managing Google plus one other platform with a handful of reviews a month, a spreadsheet and calendar reminder works fine. Paid tools earn their cost once you're juggling three-plus platforms with enough volume that manual checking becomes unreliable.
Can I ask a customer to move their review from one platform to another?
No — don't ask someone to delete and repost elsewhere, or leave duplicate reviews for the same experience. It looks manufactured and can breach platform guidelines. Ask a different customer, at a different time, for the second platform.
Does a bad review on a smaller platform actually hurt me if my Google reviews are strong?
Generally less than an equivalent bad review on Google, but it's not harmless, especially where that platform genuinely gets checked before purchase. The honest trade-off: ignoring it because "nobody really looks there" is a gamble, not a guarantee.
Should I respond to reviews on every platform myself, or can a team member do it?
A team member can absolutely do it, as long as responses are reviewed for tone before posting and there's a clear policy for negative ones — a rushed, defensive reply can do more damage than the original review.
Keep reading 🤍
I help Gold Coast and Brisbane businesses grow with branding, websites and marketing that actually works.
Work with me ✦