← Back to blog
GBPLocal SEOReputationSmall BusinessWebsite CRO

The Duplicate Google Business Profile Problem: How to Find and Merge Listings You Didn't Know Existed

04 October 2026·5 min read
Quick answer: Duplicate Google Business Profile listings usually happen because a previous agency, a data aggregator, or Google itself auto-generated a second listing from directory data, old business details, or a slightly different business name. You can find them by searching your business name plus suburb in Google Maps and checking for more than one pin, then request a merge through Google's support or the "suggest an edit" flag on the duplicate. It's worth checking even if your main profile looks fine — a duplicate quietly splits your reviews, calls and visibility without you noticing. 📱

A duplicate Google Business Profile is one of those problems that doesn't announce itself. 💖 Your main listing might look perfectly healthy — decent reviews, regular posts, accurate hours — while a second, half-abandoned listing quietly sits a few results away, splitting your reviews, confusing customers about which number to call, and occasionally outranking the listing you actually manage.

What most businesses get wrong

Most businesses only discover a duplicate when something goes visibly wrong — a customer mentions calling an old number, or a review shows up somewhere the owner didn't even know existed. Nobody checks proactively, because the assumption is that Google Business Profiles are a "set once" thing. In reality, duplicates get created more easily than people expect — a change of business name, a house move, a previous marketing agency setting up a second listing without checking for an existing one, or a data aggregator pulling outdated details into a new profile automatically.

How to find and request a merge

A simple quarterly check, especially after any rebrand, address change or change of agency:
  1. Search your exact business name + suburb in Google Maps and Google Search (logged out, or in an incognito window, so personalisation doesn't skew results).
  2. Search variations too — a previous trading name, an old address, a common misspelling — duplicates often sit under a slightly different name.
  3. If you find a second listing, check who manages it. If it's unclaimed, you may be able to claim and then merge it yourself. If it's claimed by someone else (an old staff member, a previous agency), you'll need to request ownership or flag it for merging.
  4. Use the "Suggest an edit" option on the duplicate to flag it as a duplicate of your main listing, or contact Google Business Profile support directly with both listing URLs.
  5. Keep evidence — screenshots of both listings, your business registration details — in case support asks for verification.
  6. Once merged, check reviews transferred and that the surviving listing has the correct name, address and phone number (NAP) consistent with your website and other directories.

Worked examples

A local service business that had changed trading names: found that its old business name still had an active, unclaimed Google Business Profile with a handful of old reviews attached, sitting right next to the current listing in search results and confusing customers trying to call. Claiming the old listing and merging it folded the reviews and search presence back into one place.
A business that had worked with three different marketing agencies over several years: discovered two near-identical listings when auditing its online presence — one created years earlier by an agency that never handed over login access, the other the business's current, actively managed profile. The old one was flagged as a duplicate and eventually merged, though it took several weeks of back-and-forth with Google support to resolve.
A business that had relocated premises within the same suburb: found a legacy listing still showing the old address, generating calls to a location the business no longer occupied. Rather than a true duplicate in Google's eyes initially, it had to be reported and investigated before being merged into the correctly located profile.
💡 Be honest about the timeline: merges aren't instant. Google's process can take anywhere from a few days to several weeks, and sometimes requires more than one attempt or escalation through support before it actually resolves — this isn't a same-day fix, so build in patience and follow-up.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Assuming there's only one listing because the main one looks fine. Duplicates can sit quietly without affecting the primary listing's day-to-day appearance.
  • Ignoring a duplicate because it has no reviews. It can still confuse customers with outdated contact details or split your local search visibility.
  • Creating a brand-new listing instead of checking for an old one first after a rebrand or relocation — this is exactly how duplicates get created in the first place.
  • Giving up after one rejected merge request. It's common to need to resubmit with clearer evidence or escalate through a different support channel.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know for certain two listings are duplicates and not two real locations?

Compare the address, phone number and photos closely — genuine duplicates usually share the same address or phone number with only minor naming differences, while a real second location will have its own distinct address and typically its own phone line.

Can I merge the listings myself without contacting Google support?

If you own and can verify both listings, Google sometimes merges them automatically once it detects the duplicate, but this isn't reliable or fast — for most cases you'll need to actively flag it as a duplicate or contact support directly.

Will merging duplicates always keep the reviews?

Usually the surviving listing keeps its own reviews, and in some cases reviews from the merged listing transfer across too — but this isn't guaranteed in every case, so it's worth keeping a screenshot record of reviews on both listings before requesting a merge.

How often should I check for duplicates?

A quick check once or twice a year is reasonable for most businesses, and definitely after any rebrand, relocation, or change of marketing agency — those are the moments duplicates are most likely to get created.

Keep reading 🤍

Share
Written by
Kate, founder of Chronically Online

I help Gold Coast and Brisbane businesses grow with branding, websites and marketing that actually works.

Work with me ✦