How Financial Planners Should Talk About Behavioural Coaching as Part of the Value They Provide (Not Just Returns)

27 September 2026·5 min read

Quick answer: Name the behavioural coaching part of your job explicitly — the calls talking clients out of panic-selling, the conversations that stop a bad decision at exactly the wrong moment — instead of letting it sit as invisible, unpaid emotional labour. It's a real, marketable part of the value you provide, separate from performance, and clients who understand it tend to value the relationship more, not less. 📈

Ask most financial planners what they actually do for a living and the answer is some version of "help people make better decisions with their money." Ask their marketing what they do, and it's almost always framed around strategy, structure and returns. The behavioural coaching part — arguably the part that earns the fee hardest, in exactly the moments markets get scary — barely gets a mention. 💖 That's a genuine gap, and closing it is one of the more honest, differentiating things a practice can do.

Please note: general information, not financial advice — check current official guidance before relying on it.

What most practices get wrong

There's a fear that talking about behavioural coaching sounds like admitting the investment side doesn't matter, or worse, sounds like therapy dressed up as financial advice. So it gets left out entirely, and the value proposition defaults to the safest, most comparable thing to talk about: performance and fees. The problem is that performance is the one thing you genuinely can't promise or control, and fees are the one thing every competitor is also talking about. Behavioural coaching — the actual, repeated act of keeping a client from selling at the bottom or chasing a hot tip at the top — is specific to you, happens constantly, and is one of the few things research consistently points to as adding real value over time. Leaving it out of the marketing means leaving out the part of the job that's hardest to replicate with a robo-adviser or a spreadsheet.

Ways to name the behavioural coaching value without overclaiming:

Use "the phone call that didn't happen" framing — content about the decisions clients didn't make because of a conversation first, rather than promising specific outcomes.
Describe the role plainly on your services page: "part of what you're paying for is someone in your corner during the moments markets get scary" — general, honest, not a performance claim.
Turn volatile weeks into content — a short note to your database during a market wobble that talks through staying the course, published as an example of the coaching in action.
Ask reflective questions at review meetings and note the answer: "was there a moment this year you nearly made a change and didn't — what stopped you?" Client language here is gold for later content (used generally, never attributed without permission).
Give the role a name internally so your team talks about it consistently — some practices literally use "behavioural coaching" as a listed part of their service, alongside strategy and implementation.

A client during a sharp market downturn: Calls wanting to move everything to cash. The adviser talks through the plan, the timeframe, and the history of previous downturns, and the client stays the course. Six months later, that specific conversation — not the eventual market recovery — is what gets referenced in a short, general newsletter piece on "the calls we have that never make it into a portfolio report."

A client tempted by a friend's "hot" investment tip: Brings it to their adviser expecting encouragement, and instead gets a calm, structured conversation about how it fits (or doesn't) with their existing plan. That's coaching too — it just doesn't get talked about because nothing "bad" happened. Naming this kind of moment in your marketing normalises bringing ideas to your adviser before acting on them.

A first-time investor spooked by a single bad month: New clients are often the most reactive because they haven't lived through a full cycle yet. A short, proactive check-in call after a rough month — before they call you — is a small, repeatable coaching moment worth building into your onboarding process and mentioning in client-facing materials.

Putting this into practice

Add a line to your services page that explicitly names the behavioural role, in general terms — not as a performance promise.
Build a "market volatility" communication template in advance, so you're not writing one from scratch during an actual downturn — speed matters here.
Track behavioural moments in your CRM the same way you'd track a strategy change — it's part of the service history, and useful for the value-of-advice recap conversation too.
Train new team members explicitly on this part of the role — it's often learned by osmosis rather than taught, which makes it inconsistent across a growing team.

💡 Honest nuance: this only works if it's genuinely true of how you practise. If behavioural coaching isn't something you actively do — proactively checking in, talking clients through decisions rather than just processing them — don't market it as a differentiator. Clients will notice the gap between the marketing and the actual experience fast.

Mistakes to avoid

Don't frame it as "we'll stop you making mistakes" — it can sound patronising. Frame it as being a second, calmer perspective in the room.
Don't attribute specific client stories without explicit permission, and keep any examples general and illustrative rather than presented as real case studies.
Don't use this framing to avoid talking about fees or performance altogether — it's an addition to the value story, not a replacement for being upfront about cost.
Don't only bring this up during a downturn — introducing the concept for the first time mid-crisis looks reactive rather than considered.

Frequently asked questions

Isn't talking about behavioural coaching just a way to excuse average returns?

It shouldn't be framed that way — it's a distinct part of the value, alongside strategy and implementation, not a substitute for either. If it's used to deflect from a genuine performance conversation, that's a problem with the conversation, not the framing.

How do I bring this up with a new client who's never heard of it?

Simply describe it as part of the onboarding conversation — "part of what we do is talk things through with you before a decision, especially during volatile periods" — set as an expectation early rather than introduced only in a crisis.

Does this apply to clients on a lower-touch, lower-fee service tier?

It depends on what's actually included in that tier. Only market the behavioural coaching angle for service levels where that kind of proactive contact genuinely happens.

Can I use this in advertising, not just client communication?

Yes, in general terms — describing the role and the type of support offered, without implying it guarantees better outcomes or higher returns than a client would otherwise get.

Keep reading 🤍

Written by

Kate, founder of Chronically Online

I help Gold Coast and Brisbane businesses grow with branding, websites and marketing that actually works.

Work with me ✦